Angel Next Door Spoils Me Rotten Season 2 Anime Series Review

Angel Next Door Spoils Me Rotten Season 2 Anime Series Review

To say I had no great love for the first season of The Angel Next Door Spoils Me Rotten would be like saying, “Maybe it’s possible that Amane isn’t a good boyfriend”—a statement that will make sense by the end of this review, I promise. A massive understatement that buries the lede so deep it’s in the most cobweb-coated basement of hell, nonetheless, is what I’m trying to communicate. I didn’t like its snail-like pacing; I didn’t like the inconsistent writing, and most of all, I didn’t like the romantic leads, Mahiru and Amane. And I’ll be honest: I disliked that first season so much that I didn’t think season 2 could even come close to topping it. Could it be equally as unenjoyable for me? Sure, that seems plausible. But worse—let alone substantially worse? There’s no way. Surely, we’ve already hit rock bottom, right?

R-right?

I regret to inform you that, as it turns out, the first season is only the shaky preamble to the cacophonous chronicle of courtship that is its second season.

Let’s start with the most obvious thing that looms over the entire series. These two are so intentionally avoidant of sex in the most peculiar way, and it gets brought up all the time. To be clear, it’s not that either one of them is asexual, or just doesn’t feel like they’re ready to take that step. In fact, they often talk about how frustratingly badly they yearn to have sex. Sometimes, Mahiru suggests that she’s worried about accidentally ending up pregnant—which makes you want to ask the two of them if they’ve taken sex-ed, or if they’re familiar with safe sex practices (which, incidentally, isn’t something that gets talked about in a way that’s substantial or meaningful at all), but whatever, fine, sure. That raises some unaddressed questions, but if that were it, I probably wouldn’t think twice. But alas, there’s far more to it than that.

Far more often than that—namely, just about every time they have a physical interaction of any type that lasts more than 0.2 seconds—it’s Amane talking about how much of a good boyfriend he is for holding himself back, and he proceeds to warn Mahiru that if she continues to do [insert innocuous action here], then he might not be able to anymore. Based on how the anime frames this as something noble and almost cutesy, I don’t think it realizes how sinister an undertone that gives to every interaction they have.

And yet, while it’s certainly a big part of it, that’s not even entirely why I think Amane is one of the all-time worst anime boyfriends—possibly the singular worst to ever be a romantic lead. More specifically, his jealousy levels are off the charts, and this anime constantly frames that as being cute and sweet. There’s a very dated trope in (romance) anime where jealousy was meant to be taken as a sign of affection. Thankfully, we’ve largely left this behind in the 90s and 2000s. But even if you were to compare this anime—or rather Amane in particular (although Mahiru is guilty of this at times as well)—to others that did this, his jealousy is still overwhelmingly stronger. In fact, it feels like a disservice just calling it “jealousy” rather than being extremely possessive over Mahiru.

Lest you think I’m exaggerating, here are a few examples: he frequently scolds Mahiru for innocent acts he’s arbitrarily deemed flirty. Also, there’s one moment where they’re at a summer festival together, and he tells Mahiru to tone herself down, “don’t let strangers see what a darling you are,” because he wants Mahiru, “all to [him]self.” Seconds later, his friends are talking about how charming Amane is, and you can overhear some girls in the background talk about how hot they think he is. Don’t even get me started on how bad this gets during the school festival.

To be clear, I know sometimes it’s fun to watch a doomed relationship play out—that a relationship doesn’t necessarily need to be wholesome and healthy to be entertaining. Quite the opposite: I love trashy reality TV, so I’ll be the first to agree that it’s often fun to watch what’s clearly a flawed, ill-fated relationship go its course until it eventually crashes and burns. But because the series is blind to just how terrible a boyfriend Amane is—worse, it tends to frame him as a good one—it just makes the whole thing so painfully boring to watch, because we know that no one will notice how awful this relationship is, and by extension of that, he won’t suffer any consequences. There will be no moment of confrontation, no discussion of behaviors, no drama, absolutely nothing. The problem is less about their noxious relationship itself and more about the series not being aware of it, and how frustrating and boring it becomes as a direct result of that unawareness.

As you may have noticed, the nicest way to put it is that it constantly makes it painfully obvious that Amane and Mahiru are both in their first relationship, and that this one isn’t going to last. And if this anime had been perhaps self-aware on some level and leaned into that, there might have been something else interesting there. Instead, it plays everything totally earnestly—as though it doesn’t see the bright red flags it planted. Despite this anime’s utter obtuseness, Amane’s intense jealousy makes the relationship feel toxic at best, and downright doomed at worst to anyone who’s paying attention. And yet, this anime would seriously have its audience suspend collective disbelief to the furthest possible limits, convincing us this is cute, good, and proof they’re soulmates? That’s absurd, come on.

But the frustrations with this anime go further than the writing and characters. The production values do this anime no favors, either. While it looks softer and a clear step up from season 1, the visuals and animation still have a lot of room for improvement. Moreover, there are so many long gaps in this anime without any background music that it gives the whole thing an unsettling, weirdly empty vibe. The voice acting, at least, is fine, if still a bit stifled by questionable direction similar to the first season.

This is, unequivocally, one of the worst romance anime I’ve ever seen. Not just of the year, not just of the decade, but ever. The writing is clearly and legibly on the wall about Mahiru and Amane’s deeply unhealthy relationship, and everyone can read it just fine except for this anime itself. And there’s something eye-roll-inducing and aggravating about watching this play out.

Read More

Zaļā Josta - Reklāma