Zig Crane will do anything as long as the coin is good. As a mercenary, he lives and dies by his fighting prowess, so when he takes on a job to exterminate a witch, it’s just another day’s work. When the Silent Witch Siasha ends up at the end of Zig’s blade, he asks her a single question: why do you kill? Siasha’s answer, that she kills only to stop people from trying to kill her, prompts Zig to realize that they aren’t so different after all. Siasha, like him, kills by circumstance rather than inclination. More importantly, she has the means to pay him.
Fed up with the same old battlefields, he takes a new job: escorting Siasha to the Unknown Continent, a legendary place where she hopes to be free of the persecution that has defined her life so far.
Witch and Mercenary doesn’t waste much more time in Zig and Siasha’s home country. We skip to a sea voyage that culminates in a monster attack, where our unlikely duo emerges as the only survivors. Surviving thanks to Zig’s experience traversing hostile environments, they make their way to a small village and try to figure out the lay of the land. So far, so peachy, except we soon discover that magic is commonplace in the Unknown Continent, and that it’s Zig’s brutal fighting skills that are ostracised rather than Siasha’s magic.
Thanks to the plague of monstrosities living in this magical land, large-scale battles are nothing more than beacons to which monsters are drawn. What use, therefore, is someone whose sole purpose is to fight against other people?
The dynamics are flipped, but because Siasha is as unused to people as Zig is to this continent, both are fish out of water. New land, new rules, a new way of life to get used to, and no real way home: the setting of Witch and Mercenary is, for all intents and purposes, an isekai. I’ll admit this surprised me, since the initial premise made me think the story would focus more on the consequences of their role reversal. Zig would have to come to terms with his skills being undervalued, and Siasha would embrace her role as a witch openly and without fear. But if they’re both lost on arrival, where do we go? Turns out Siasha wants to blend in while living amongst people, and she’s keen to see the positive aspects of humanity. And Zig, refreshingly, doesn’t give a damn what others think. To that end, the pair soon end up in the town of Halian, where an adventurer’s guild eagerly awaits their arrival.
This is where the story requires a bit of patience. After such a strong opening hook, the mechanics of how the guild works take up a lot of space on the page, leading to Witch and Mercenary‘s first volume feeling slow-paced and even saggy at points. The day-to-day of being an adventurer feels formulaic (how many times do we need to be told there are ranks of adventurers before it gets hammered home that this is a hierarchical company stand-in?), and the repeated scenes of Siasha battling low-tier monsters lose their shine quickly.
Adventurers also primarily earn money and complete requests by carving up and selling valuable monster parts, a premise we’ve seen done better elsewhere, like in Campfire Cooking in Another World with My Absurd Skill. What’s more, there isn’t much variance in monster types so far, meaning Siasha leaves a whole lot of chopped-up insects in her wake. Appetizing!
Stick with the story, though, because if you can ignore the lackluster scene-setting, then the character payoff is worth it. For one, I enjoyed the twist that Zig himself doesn’t become an adventurer, sticking to his job as Siasha’s bodyguard and staying in a supporting role. This keeps it from feeling like an isekai power fantasy with a hero and his adoring companion; while we’re largely in Zig’s head, much of the narrative follows Siasha’s efforts to raise her rank and become an elite adventurer. The central mystery of her background is another hook to keep you reading, as by the end of volume two both Zig and the reader are no closer to finding out what makes her tick.
Characters aside, action fans will appreciate that the initial exposition-heavy battles soon give way to several excellent combat sequences. From a katana-wielding adventurer to a serial killer and a horde of rampaging creatures, Witch and Mercenary tries hard to deliver beyond the boring beetles of the beginning.
The fights are easy to follow as Zig thinks through his moves logically, relying on hard work and consistency rather than pure talent, a mindset which keeps him alive throughout clashes against Siasha and other fierce opponents. He has a calm personality and seems impervious to provocation, and his actions often border on cold or even unsympathetic. As a witch – which we’re told early on is a different species entirely from humans – Siasha is also a calculating fighter, leading to brutally efficient battles with a non-insignificant volume of gore.
This continues in the second volume, where the pair inevitably find themselves pitted against human opponents. It’s refreshing to read something where the characters don’t hesitate to fight to the death, and are in fact entirely unbothered by the concept. In the afterword, author Kaeru Chōhōkiteki worries whether that makes Zig and Siasha hard to empathize with, but it’s balanced nicely with their more relatable characteristics, like worrying about money (inescapable even in an escapist fantasy, unfortunately). I might not fully understand why Zig and Siasha act the way they do, but they’re consistent in their behaviors, and there’s plenty of scope for their attitudes to evolve over the next volumes.
One neat way Witch and Mercenary explores this character growth is through its slowly expanding cast of recurring characters. The first volume moves at a glacial pace when it comes to human relations, but the second follows through with a slew of adventurers owing Zig favors, shop vendors thinking about their now-loyal clients, and guild staff beginning to come into their own. Mix in some mafia nefariousness and a clan of sword-wielding, elflike people called the Jinsu-Yah, and we start to see Zig and Siasha interact with others outside of their outcast partnership.
There are even the beginnings of a slow-burn romance. Although their relationship is strictly professional on the surface, it’s clear our protagonists are drawn to one another, even if they don’t fully realize why. I anticipate it’ll be a long wait before we see any real romance, if there’s any at all, because they both need to learn how to be people first. Still, if you squint hard enough, you can see hints of it in Siasha’s stirrings of jealousy and in Zig brushing her hair, along with other subtle moments highlighted by Bench Kanase‘s sketchlike illustrations. Given that Zig keeps getting acquainted with attractive young women and Siasha is an object of popular desire, the later volumes may need an inciting incident to get the ball rolling.
As we move into the third volume in the series, I’m looking forward to what trials Zig and Siasha will face next, but I have questions that I feel we really should be getting some answers to. What is a witch, and why are they so long-lived? What happened to all the monstrosities on the Old Continent? And just how big is the town of Halian, anyway? I hope the next volumes delve into Siasha’s head to help us find out, but for now, I’ll be content with more scenes of the Silent Witch figuring out her favorite skewer at the food stalls.











