Universal Music Group EVP and chief digital officer Michael Nash. Photo Credit: UMG
Universal Music Group (UMG) has doubled down on its “walled garden” support and confirmed plans for a superfan-geared expansion powered by digital platforms as well as in-person experiential events.
UMG chief digital officer Michael Nash and CFO Matt Ellis covered these and other interesting subjects during a discussion at Morgan Stanley’s European Technology, Media and Telecom conference in Barcelona. Beginning on the AI side, a growing pile of evidence, from Tencent Music consumption disclosures to distributor-level streaming stats, suggests fans aren’t wild about machine-generated audio.
And as we broke down yesterday, Universal Music’s kicked in a bit more evidence with its own research: “North of 80%” of U.S. consumers support the rollout of an AI audio “kill switch” on DSPs, per Nash.
Naturally, the subject of listener disdain for AI tracks on established services tied back to the heated “walled garden” debate during the panel.
In a nutshell, Universal Music and Sony Music have made clear with their aggressive Suno litigation that they think gen AI outputs should stay on the platform at hand as opposed to hitting Spotify, Apple Music, and others.
Meanwhile, Warner Music Group (WMG), Believe, and BMG have licensed Suno, which has retooled its rules and implemented download limits but still enables users to upload generations to DSPs.
Is the walled garden emphasis harming the industry in terms of lost revenue and otherwise? WMG head Robert Kyncl believes so and wasn’t subtle about calling out “AI resistance” at the Amplify Music Investment Summit this past May, including by comparing the current response to the missteps made during the rise of digital.
Now, Nash has seemingly responded to the criticism, in part by clarifying Universal Music’s definition of a “walled garden” as “a self-sustaining ecosystem” geared towards and tailored for superfans.
“And the basic concept is that you enable superfans on a higher tier of premium subscription to interact directly with the music and artists that they love, to create remixes, mashups, and custom songs,” he reiterated.
“I think that there’s been a gross oversimplification of this idea of closed versus open [AI platforms],” Nash said. “And some people have invoked the mistakes that were made with DRM and music downloads back at the beginning of the century. Digital rights management is how all music subscription works. It’s how Spotify works. It’s how Apple Music works. It’s how Amazon Music works. It’s how Netflix works. It’s how all of SVOD works.
“Embedding rights management into the creation and the distribution of the content and the authentication of the relationship with the consumer is the evolution of digital rights with respect to the streaming economy that’s been responsible for the blossoming of the streaming economy. So this idea that we’re suggesting something that is new and different and more limited, and that’s not how the world works, is basically a complete flip of reality.”
Translation: Universal Music remains on a far different page than Warner Music when it comes to AI – a fact underscored by Nash’s follow-up remarks about artist opt-ins for non-walled models.
“But the additional component of the equation is we’re not asking artists to support the creation of content that then gets posted all over the ecosystem and competes directly with the artists for streams and for monetization,” Nash stated. “We don’t think we would be successful in getting artists to opt into a new model that would basically dilute them and result in a lot of cannibalistic content.”
At the same time, the higher-up acknowledged the need “to get to critical mass to support the launch of these new [gen AI] products.” Here, the major is “literally conducting conversations with thousands and thousands of artists” and is on its “way to achieving the internal goal” for opt-ins, he disclosed.
Elsewhere during the discussion, Nash and Ellis highlighted streaming’s global growth outlook, to the tune of an anticipated one billion worldwide subscribers by 2028 and possibly 1.5 billion by the mid-2030s notwithstanding any quarterly fluctuations along the way.
Unsurprisingly, they also touched on their plans to improve ARPU, especially in generally difficult-to-monetize emerging markets.
“Understanding how we can utilize the content differentiation for paid versus free in China led us to this experiment in India,” Nash said of the major’s decision to paywall new releases for 72 hours. “We hope that the results continue to trend in the right direction. And I think what we’re learning in India could be very applicable to other markets where you have a high level of engagement in streaming, but a low level of paid conversion.”
More broadly, the execs don’t appear particularly worried about the possibility that price bumps might fuel churn, and their longstanding objective of improving Family monetization hasn’t changed. Streaming 2.0 agreements, Nash spelled out, will address this and different “issues” such as “how the platforms are managing fraud.”
Admittedly, we’ve heard a lot about those topics over the years – and comparatively little about how Patrick Whitesell-partnered Universal Music intends to step up its monetization game in the superfan and IRL spaces.
“D2C is an area we’ve spoken about a bit,” Ellis communicated. “I think we’re ready to see a next step there, whether it be on the physical side or the digital side of D2C, where we spoke earlier this year about a couple of relationships with Even and Stationhead as examples of where you can enhance the superfan business and allow artists to have a direct relationship with their fans in a different way.
“And then I think some of the experiential, right? Obviously, ABBA Voyage has been very successful for the past few years; we’ve had an involvement with that. I think you see the opportunity for that, and there’s a number of other projects in the works with similar constructs and so on that you should expect to see us continue to be part of.
“So yes, the digital side will be very important, but these other revenue streams, I think, have got tremendous opportunity as well over the next few years,” he finished.











