Beyond ‘Going Limbic’: What Happens To Leadership Under Pressure

Beyond ‘Going Limbic’: What Happens To Leadership Under Pressure

Paula Johnston is the founder of NeuCoach and creator of Living Systems Leadership, with 30+ years in leadership development.

getty

For years, I have used a simple explanation for what happens to leaders under pressure: The prefrontal cortex supports our executive thinking, while the “limbic brain” can take over when we feel threatened.

Many of us know the language. We “go limbic.” We experience an “amygdala hijack.” Our emotional brain takes over.

It has been useful shorthand because the experience behind it is real. A difficult conversation begins and something shifts. Our breathing changes, our stomach tightens, we may feel heat rise through the body and our attention narrows. We become more defensive, more directive or less curious.

The experience is real. The explanation needs updating.

Neuroscientist Joseph LeDoux has spent decades challenging the idea of the amygdala as a simple “fear center.” In his 2014 Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences paper, “Coming to Terms With Fear,” LeDoux distinguishes the mechanisms involved in detecting and responding to threats from those involved in our conscious experience of fear.

The familiar idea of one limbic “emotional brain” overpowering a rational cortex is also too simple. Contemporary neuroscience gives us a much more interconnected picture.

The old metaphor pointed toward something important: Under pressure, our capacity to think and respond can change quickly. The science now gives us a better explanation.

What changes under pressure?

Yale neuroscientist Amy Arnsten provides an important part of that explanation. Her 2015 Nature Neuroscience review, “Stress Weakens Prefrontal Networks: Molecular Insults to Higher Cognition,” describes how acute, uncontrollable stress can alter prefrontal functioning.

The prefrontal cortex supports working memory, flexible thinking, inhibition and considered decision making. Under significant stress, high levels of catecholamines—chemical messengers including norepinephrine and dopamine—can weaken the prefrontal networks supporting these capabilities. Faster defensive and habitual responses can become more influential.

The body is involved too. Stress systems mobilize us for action. Heart rate can change, attention may narrow and some people experience heat or flushing.

A separate emotional brain is not heating up and physically short-circuiting a rational one. Conditions across interconnected brain-body systems are shifting, influencing what we notice and how flexibly we respond.

A more useful description may be that we shift into protection. Under pressure, we can move from a more responsive state toward a protective one. Thinking may narrow, habitual responses become easier to access and control can suddenly feel much more attractive.

The sensation is real. The first interpretation may not be.

Interoception adds another important piece.

Interoception is our capacity to sense signals arising from within the body. Benedict Greenwood and Sarah Garfinkel’s 2025 Annual Review of Psychology paper, “Interoceptive Mechanisms and Emotional Processing,” explores how bodily information contributes to emotional experience alongside higher-order processes that help us interpret those signals in context.

A racing heart does not arrive with its meaning attached. It might accompany anxiety, anticipation, excitement, exertion or anger. Previous experience, expectation and context influence the interpretation we make.​

Imagine a leader whose proposal is questioned during an important meeting. They notice an immediate physical response and interpret it as a challenge to their authority. Their speech speeds up, their tone sharpens and they begin explaining more and listening less.

Another leader may notice a similar shift and remain open long enough to consider that the questions contain information they have not yet understood.

Once our interpretation begins influencing pace, tone, language and behavior, our internal state has entered the relationship.

This is the Neuroception of Leadership.

This is where my work on Living Systems Leadership has taken me deeper.

Pressure can make certainty more attractive. It can narrow the questions we ask and make conflicting information harder to hear. Other people experience those changes through our attention, language, tone, pace and behavior.

We also need to be careful about using neuroscience to diagnose others. A crossed arm is not a neurological diagnosis. Silence does not have one meaning. We cannot know with certainty that someone is “in threat” simply by observing their behavior.

Psychologist Stephen Porges introduced the term neuroception within Polyvagal Theory to describe a proposed process through which cues associated with safety and threat are evaluated outside conscious awareness.

Acknowledging Porges’ original concept, and drawing more broadly on research into defensive processing, stress physiology, interoception and human interaction, I have developed an applied leadership framework called The Neuroception of Leadership. Its central proposition is that the state a leader brings becomes part of the environment others experience.

Our state influences the signals we send. Other people interpret those signals through their own experiences, expectations and current state. Their response becomes new information for us, and the interaction continues to move.

What language serves leaders better now?

We do not need to lose the simplicity that made “going limbic” useful. We can update it.

Pressure can shift us from responsive to protective. Our state influences how we perceive and respond. Our response becomes part of the environment others experience. That gives us somewhere useful to intervene.

Notice the state. Check the interpretation. Choose the response.

Before a difficult conversation, consider three questions:

1. What has shifted in my body?

2. What meaning am I giving that shift?

3. What might my response set in motion around me?

Leadership does not require permanent calm. It requires enough awareness to notice when our state is shaping our response and enough flexibility to choose what the situation actually needs.

Behavior is the output. State is the source.


Forbes Coaches Council is an invitation-only community for leading business and career coaches. Do I qualify?


Read More

Zaļā Josta - Reklāma