Dr. Mark Khater, Swiss Bridge Capital board member and Cambridge’s Centre for Strategy & Performance, advises on AI and is a fintech CEO.
getty
A senior executive I have worked with for several years invited me to review the aftermath of a failed strategic initiative. His leadership team had identified a market opportunity, assembled a rigorous business case and secured board approval. The strategy was sound. The analysis was thorough. But six months later, the initiative had stalled, and the team was divided over what had gone wrong.
“We all agreed on the direction,” he told me. “I just assumed that meant we all understood how to get there.”
He was describing, without knowing it, what I see as the most common and least examined cause of strategic failure.
The Variable That Strategy Forgot
Strategy theory has devoted decades to the question of what makes organizations competitive. We have frameworks for positioning, for identifying valuable and rare resources, for building dynamic capabilities that adapt to changing markets. What we have paid far less attention to is the mechanism that determines whether any of it works. That mechanism is coordination.
Coordination is the ability to align people, processes and decisions around a shared understanding of what matters and how to act on it. It is not the same as agreement. Agreement is easy. A room full of executives can agree on a strategic direction in an afternoon. Coordination requires that the same room can translate that direction into aligned action across functions, timelines and competing priorities. Most cannot.
The evidence is consistent. Research published in the Harvard Business Review found that 30% of executives cite failure to coordinate across units as the single greatest challenge to executing strategy. The intelligence was there, but the coordination was absent.
The Coordination Curse
Failing to coordinate causes damage. Failing to recognize that coordination has gone wrong is worse. This is what I call silent coordination failure, and it is the more dangerous version of what I have come to think of as the coordination curse.
Silent coordination failure occurs when an organization is perfectly aligned and moving with speed and confidence, but it’s aligned on the wrong thing. Everyone has access to the same data. Everyone is using the same models. Everyone believes they have reached an independent conclusion. The alignment feels like validation, but it’s actually a convergence produced by shared inputs, not shared wisdom.
In one case I witnessed, an AI system in a financial services firm qualified a particular stock as a strong investment opportunity. It met every quantitative criterion. A human analyst reviewing the same position identified an emerging reputational risk that no model had been trained to detect. Without that human layer, the firm would have moved with perfect coordination into a position it would later have had to explain to its clients.
Artificial intelligence (AI) can deepen this problem. When every team relies on the same models and training data, they can reach similar conclusions while overlooking the same risks, especially when they no longer bring their own experience and independent judgment to the decision. The organization becomes faster and more aligned, but alignment without independent judgment is a vulnerability, not an advantage.
Three Principles For Coordination That Works
1. Test for alignment rather than just agreement.
Agreement asks whether people support the direction. Alignment asks whether they understand their role in executing it, what trade-offs they are prepared to make and where their obligations intersect with those of other functions. Having alignment can be the difference between a strategy that survives a board presentation and one that survives contact with reality.
2. Use the technology to disprove your thesis and its underlying assumptions.
The instinct in most organizations is to use data and models to confirm a thesis. The more valuable discipline is to ask what would make the thesis wrong. AI is a powerful tool for stress-testing assumptions, but only if the organization has the intellectual honesty to act on what it finds.
3. Preserve the judgment that catches what convergence misses.
The human in the loop helps maintain the diversity of perspective upon which sound coordination depends. It is far more than a compliance layer or a checkbox before the automated recommendation goes live. Organizations that remove it in pursuit of speed are dismantling the one safeguard that machines cannot replicate.
Coordination that works requires something many organizations find uncomfortable: the willingness to ask whether the direction is wrong, and the courage to act on the answer. Ego is the enemy of this process. The instinct to defend a position because capital and reputation have been committed to it is understandable. It is also how silent coordination failure compounds. Wisdom begins by admitting that the conclusion may need to change.
Where It Fell Apart
The executive I described at the outset had a strategy. What he lacked was the coordination to translate it into aligned action, and the mechanisms to detect when alignment had become convergence. His team had agreed, but they had never coordinated. The difference cost them a year and a market position they have not recovered.
The organizations that should worry most are the ones with perfect coordination and the wrong destination. The ones that will endure are those with the courage to question the destination while there is still time to change course.
Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?











