getty
Marketing campaigns generate plenty of data, but the numbers don’t always tell a clear story. Engagement may be climbing while conversions lag, or one platform may report results that don’t match another. With budgets, expectations and business goals riding on those results, knowing what to trust matters. Figures that seem to conflict can make it difficult to determine what’s working and where to focus resources.
Understanding what the numbers are actually measuring is essential to making informed marketing decisions. Here, members of Forbes Agency Council share how they approach misaligned or conflicting metrics to determine which signals deserve closer attention.
1. Check Whether Metrics Are Actually Comparable
Start by checking whether the metrics use the same audience, time frame, definitions and attribution model. Then ask what each measures: reach, engagement, conversion or revenue. Strong engagement and weak sales can coexist because they reflect different stages of the journey. Align the data and trace the path to conversion. A real contradiction persists after those differences are accounted for; different views help explain where performance breaks down. – Elyse Flynn Meyer, Prism Global Marketing Solutions
2. Follow Closed Revenue, Not Platform Proxies
Proxies disagree by design. Platform conversions exist to train an algorithm, analytics exist to describe traffic and the CRM exists to tell the CFO what closed. Reconciling them is the wrong exercise. Pull the last two quarters and ask which of the conflicting numbers moved ahead of closed revenue. That one earns a vote in the budget. The other is a dashboard, and dashboards contradict nothing. – Aaron Domino, Onimod Global
3. Put Business Outcomes Ahead Of Platform Dashboards
When campaign metrics diverge, start with the business outcome, not the platform dashboard. Confirm tracking, then align metric definitions, audiences, time periods and attribution windows before comparing channel results. Engagement and visits can indicate interest; qualified leads, pipeline and revenue show business impact. Read together, these measures help leaders decide what to optimize and where to invest. – Amy Packard Berry, Sparkpr
Forbes Agency Council is an invitation-only community for executives in successful public relations, media strategy, creative and advertising agencies. Do I qualify?
4. Look Beyond The Gap To Understand Prospect Quality
I look at what changed between the numbers, not just the gap itself. A campaign may attract fewer visitors yet bring in more valuable prospects because the message is reaching a more relevant audience. The key is to trace how each result influences the next business decision. If the pattern cannot be explained by customer behavior, it may signal a genuine measurement issue. – Vaibhav Kakkar, Digital Web Solutions
5. Determine Whether The Metrics Should Move Together
Before calling two metrics contradictory, ask whether they were expected to move together. Reach, engagement, qualified leads and revenue operate at different stages and often on different timelines. A real contradiction exists when two measures of the same outcome point in opposite directions after the audience and time period are aligned. Otherwise, the numbers may simply be showing where performance is strong and where it starts to break down. – Goran Paun, ArtVersion
6. Account For Search Behavior Beyond Clicks
Check what each number counts before deciding they disagree. Clicks falling while branded searches and AI mentions rise is one story seen from two windows: The buyer learned the name and skipped the click. We sort every metric by the question it answers: who noticed, who looked and who bought. A real contradiction is two metrics answering the same question differently, which is rarer than it looks. – Boris Dzhingarov, ESBO Ltd
7. Connect Individual Metrics To The Business Objective
Not every mismatch is a contradiction. Reach, engagement, search visibility and conversions tell different parts of the story. The mistake is treating them as competing scorecards. Start with the business objective, then trace how each metric contributes to it. If awareness is up but action isn’t, that’s a signal worth investigating. Don’t cherry-pick numbers to prove success. Connect the dots to understand what’s working and what’s not. – Lars Voedisch, PRecious Communications
8. Match The Metric To The Decision
Most of the time, metrics that don’t line up are answering different questions. Platform-reported conversions, media mix models and incrementality tests all measure performance. They differ in what they count, the period they cover and their attribution logic. A budget decision needs the metric closest to causation, and a creative decision needs the one closest to attention. – Josh Campo, Huge
9. Interpret The Numbers Through Audience Behavior
Marketers need to have a deep understanding of the behavior of their audience. Without this, the metrics are just numbers. If you can put yourself in the shoes of the audience, the metrics become stories about what potential customers are doing and why they do it. These stories quickly lead to real insight into what is happening and why metrics apparently contradict each other. – Mike Maynard, Napier Partnership Limited
10. Follow Performance Across The Customer Journey
Conflicting numbers often mean you’re looking at different parts of the customer journey. A campaign can have low engagement but still generate strong qualified pipeline, so the metrics may not actually disagree. Connect channel performance to the full journey and business outcomes before deciding something is underperforming. – Solomon Thimothy, Clickx
11. Add Qualitative Context To The Analytics
Different metrics can tell different truths. Hard analytics show what happened, but context determines what it means. We use soft analytics to look at the messaging goal, audience response and qualitative signals around the numbers. The question is not which metric is right, but what each one is actually measuring. – Pierce Kafka, Kafka Media Group
12. Distinguish Causation From Correlation
The greatest challenge in understanding metrics and using them to determine what “works” and what doesn’t comes down to the difference between causation and correlation. Very often, the brain will play tricks on us—as it desperately wants to assign responsibility and cause and effect in the simplest possible way. Tracking and solving for root causes always lead to success. Tracking correlation metrics and making changes based on them almost always leads to the opposite. – Josh Yudin, The Academy of Marketing
13. Track The Same Leads Through To Sales
First, ask whether the numbers should agree. More leads and fewer sales can both be true if a campaign is attracting fewer qualified buyers. Follow the same group of leads through to sales, allowing enough time for them to convert. If two reports disagree about those same sales, check what each counts, when it counts them and which campaign gets credit. That helps you distinguish a campaign problem from a reporting difference. – Stephen Gilbert, Anchour
15. Ask Whether The Difference Changes The Decision
Ask one question: Would these two numbers lead you to make different decisions? For example, if Meta says 400 conversions and GA4 says 250, but both say the campaign is working, that’s just attribution doing its thing. If one says scale and the other says cut, you’ve got a real contradiction. That’s when we dig into tracking, attribution windows and definitions. – Anthony Saniger, Act Second











